
“The Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC) almost seems designed to flunk an autistic person: it is a completely verbal, timed test that relies heavily on cultural and social knowledge. ” -Scientific American
Mainstream public schools supposedly offer educational instruction to everyone. However, children who think and learn in ways not accommodated for in public schools are often labeled uneducable, mentally retarded, or otherwise unfit to learn. Several great articles chronicling the success (often outside the mainstream school system) and contributions of outside-the-box learners highlight their amazing potential.
Scientific American’s article on The Hidden Potential of Autistic Kids raises some very important points about how school systems view and evaluate autistic children. According to the article, researchers have long labeled autistic children mentally retarded. Yet, when researchers examined the data,they concluded that expectations for autistics is based on really bad data. Using test results from popular WISC tests, educators conclude that autistic children cannot learn. Perhaps they do not learn the same way other people do and non-verbal test results prove this. Instead of looking at what autistic people are not good at, schools can find where autistic students can excel and support these out-of-the-box thinkers.
Laurent Mottron, a psychiatrist at the University of Montreal, proposes that autism is not really a disease — it is just a different way of looking at the world. Let us celebrate autistic people for their differences instead of viewing them through the lens of a disease.
Jo-Ann Tracey shares her story on The Innovative Educator blog. Her son, unable to read at age 9, was labeled uneducable by the school system, labeled ADD, medicated, and was “written off” by the system. With little options open to the Traceys, they began unschooling their son. Amazingly, Jo-Ann discovers her son’s love of reading (in spite of his difficulties in learning to read). As he progressed through unschooling, he learned to cook, repair and build computers,and carpentry. When he realized he wanted to study planetary geologist, he used online tools to learn algebra, calculus, chemistry, and physics. Even though he had problems physically writing with a pencil, he obtained passing marks in a writing course and is now a college student. A young man label uneducable by the system is on his way to becoming a planetary geologist.
Too many learners are being “tossed-out” of education systems because they cannot learn in a mainstream way. Denying opportunities to learn based on strict, narrowly targeted test results is a shame. However, an even bigger disservice to these children is that they are often very bright, creative thinkers, and passionate about learning. Personalized learning environments, geared to how these learners think, make a huge difference. While schools may continue to label and limit “out of the box” thinkers, unschooling provides a personalized learning environment that nurtures confidence, passion, and a rewarding path forward for these learners.